Well if the argument has simply come down to
I have yet to see ANYWHERE where the town gains from a supermarket
Then let's see:
Employment Tesco employs 225 people and is about to increase that by 160 more.
The town's economy needs employers like these or 385 more people would be unemployed adding to the councils deficit because less people will be paying local taxes.
Local companies rely on supermarkets like the "FREE" bus services from local housing estates to the supermarket and back. Tesco pay for this and that adds more jobs to the stack
Local Taxi firms who operate free phone services from supermarkets.
Local producers (remember Tesco stocks local produce) This includeds local veg, milk, Mead wins, Cornish Fairings, Rowes Pasties, Cornish Fudge, Cornishman newspapers, Cornishworld newspapers and many, many more locally produced products that rely on the kind of sales that supermarkets generate
Local Council who claim business taxes on the store, also the larger the car park the more tax paid.
Local cardboard collection firms like "Man and Van"
Local police who utilise modern technology like Blue tooth to warn shoppers of crimes and or urgent police appeals like missing persons.
Local charities collect at supermarkets... ones like Round Table, Lions Club, local branches of RSPCA, schools and even Picture Penzance (we do so at supermarkets because we get a bigger return than anywhere else)
Supermarkets are convenient to shop in, safe and secure (often employing security guards)
24 hour shopping for those who work odd hours, not like the old days when after 9pm you couldn't buy petrol (how we take that for vantage now).
Supermarkets have brought the cost of goods down. Now I know you'll argue that this was at the cost of local shops, but I would argue that those shops needed to diversify and adapt to their business environment. An example of this is the state of Penzance today... not dead! no but we have different kinds of businesses instead.
Ponsendane has been underused for well over 30 years. With the occasional circus, summer tenting and market garden shop. To be honest you could count on one hand how often the field had been utilised over the past many years.
The brook has all but been abandoned by the authorities and this was part of the subject we spoke about in 2008. Yet Tesco will have to maintain the land with a regular maintenance schedule.... surely this is better than the situation as it is now?
The wetlands are to be moved but at least maintained as mentioned above. What schedule has Cornwall Council for this.
Supermarkets have been around since the 60's and they are here to stay. The fact is that they will expand because there is a growing demand for them.
A huge amount of locals rely on supermarkets for so many reasons... not just to shop in. But that said, just take a look around this town on any bank holiday and see the queue for bread and milk when the local shops close down for a day off.
So I don't think that we should be discussing what supermarkets do for the town, as that is rather academic since they are already here.
To sum up I'm not disagreeing with anyone about the future of the brook and wetlands and I for one will be keeping an eye on the project to make sure they do as they say they will.... Rather, in this case I don't think Tesco is the villain here. I would rather see a proper schedule maintenance of the area and if that means Tesco well so be it. Not wanting to go off topic here but take a look at Slade Harbour as an example of care and maintenance by the council.... now that's criminal!